I just finished this one. I really enjoyed Maguire's storytelling. Like "Wicked," Maguire sets out to tell the other side of the fairy tale... this time the story of one of Cinderella's ugly step sisters. Although, "ugly" is a debatable term, as debatable as beauty itself. In fact, more and more as I read this, I was reminded of the old adage "beauty is in the eye of the beholder." And also "beauty is only skin deep."
Maguire allows us to meet the ugly step sisters first... Ruth, who is often described by her own mother as a stone or an ox and Iris, a plain girl who, as a woman, would surely turn no one's head. Their mother is a grasping woman who constantly cuts her own children down to make her point - people should give me things out of pity for my curses. Her children are those curses and she has no love nor charity for them at all.
Clara, or Cinderella, is an extremely beautiful - some might say supernaturally beautiful - girl who had led a sheltered life, locked away from everyone. By chance, these three unlike little girls are thrown together first as playmates and then as stepsisters. Clara is socially awkward, shy, and because of the upbringing she's had from her mother, useless and spoiled. Her only value is in beautiful, and when her mother is gone, she does not know what to do with herself.
I'll admit that I cannot remember what the mother, Margarthe, was described to look like. She remains in my mind as a carrion bird, scavenging the Holland country side for someone to pay for her excesses. Though she masks her greed (poorly) as concern for the welfare of her children, it is clear that she has no charity or love in her at all.
Her plain daughter, Iris, is caught between them. She is not excessively beautiful, as Clara, and although she is not educated, she has a well-meaning heart, is loyal family and friends, and above all, feels love in her heart. She is kind to both her sisters, but is also quick to believe the poison her mother spews as potential truth. She can be gentle and generous, but also catty and jealous.
In the end, it is Ruth, the sister described as a deformed, stupid, plodding ox who is the essence of true beauty. Inner beauty, that is. She alone, because of her physical deformities, is left out of the plotting, scheming lives of her mother and sisters. She's often an afterthought in their daily routines. This puts her in the position to see and hear things the others do not. The things she does - burning the painting - are done for pure reasons, even if she cannot understand them. What is more, she meant no harm, only to free the people she loved - the Master, Clara and Iris - from the stones which hung around their necks ever since the painting of the Young Girl with Tulips. In that, she succeeded. Each of them found happiness in their freedom, including Ruth herself.